4 Best Toasters for English Muffins in 2026
Choosing the right toaster for English muffins in 2026 might seem straightforward, but not all models handle the task equally well. You need a machine with wide slots—up to 10 inches—so your muffins don’t get stuck, plus adjustable browning for that perfect, evenly toasted crunch. Safety features like automatic shutoff and high-lift levers matter too, especially when dealing with hot, stubborn muffins. So, which models combine these features reliably? The answers might surprise you.
Bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Shade Control
If you want to make perfect English muffins without taking up too much space on your counter, the Bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Shade Control could be just what you need. It’s small and sleek, measuring only 3.58 inches deep. That means it fits easily in tight spots and still looks nice in your kitchen.
This toaster has a wide 10-inch slot. It can hold big English muffins, bagels, or thick bread slices easily. You don’t have to cut or squeeze your bread to make it fit. You can choose how dark or light you want your toast with six shade levels. So, you can get it just how you like it.
The toaster is easy to use. It has auto-centered guides to make sure your bread stays in the right spot. The high-lift lever helps you grab small pieces easily. It weighs only 2.46 pounds, making it lightweight and easy to handle. It also has safety features like auto shutoff to prevent burning. Plus, cleaning is simple with its removable crumb tray.
This toaster is perfect for people who want a small, stylish device. It can handle different kinds of bread and lets you control the browning level. It works great for English muffins and bagels.
Pros:
- Small design helps save space on your counter
- Wide slot fits big bread and muffins
- Plenty of shade options and safety features
Cons:
- Only toasts two slices at a time, so it’s not best for large families
- Slightly more expensive than basic toasters
- Its shiny surface can show dust or fingerprints, so you may need to wipe it often
If you like a compact, stylish toaster that makes perfect toast for English muffins and bagels, this is a good choice.
bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Multiple Settings
The Bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster is a great choice if you want a stylish and useful toaster that doesn’t take up much space. It is very slim, only 3.58 inches wide, so it fits easily on most countertops. You can pick from five nice colors: Oatmilk, Surf, Plum, Seaglass, and Blossom. The toaster has a large 10-inch slot, so you can toast big bagels, thick bread, or Texas toast evenly. It uses auto-centering guides, which help toast your bread just right.
This toaster has six shade settings, so you can choose how dark you want your toast. It also has a reheat button and a cancel button for added convenience. The 900-watt power heats up quickly and gives consistent toasting every time. It is a helpful, good-looking, and dependable kitchen tool.
Best for: People who want a small, pretty toaster with flexible options for even toasting and quick results.
Pros:
- Fits on most counters because it is only 3.58 inches wide.
- Multiple shade settings and auto-centering guides for easy control.
- Easy to clean with a removable crumb tray and safety features to prevent jams.
Cons:
- Only makes 2 slices at a time, so it may not work well for big families.
- Comes in only five colors, so options are limited.
- Some settings need manual operation and do not have digital controls.
This toaster is simple to use, looks nice, and works fast. It is a good choice if you want a small, reliable toaster that makes perfect toast every time.
Proctor Silex 2-Slice Toaster with Wide Slots
The Proctor Silex 2-Slice Toaster is a handy gadget for people who like to toast thicker bread, like English muffins or bagels. Its wide slots are big enough to hold thicker slices comfortably. You don’t have to squeeze or press down hard.
It has seven shade settings, so you can choose how light or dark you want your toast. The toast boost feature helps lift small or deep slices so you can grab them easily. It’s safe to touch the sides because the walls stay cool. Plus, it has a removable crumb tray that catches crumbs and makes cleanup simple.
This toaster is lightweight at only 2.2 pounds. It’s small enough to fit easily on your counter. It works well for those who want to toast thick bread and need control over browning. It’s simple to use and keeps your kitchen clean and safe.
Best For: People who make thick toast or bagels often and want easy control over how their toast looks.
Pros:
- Big wide slots fit thicker bread, bagels, and muffins easily
- Seven choices for browning, so you get your perfect toast
- Removable crumb tray keeps your toaster clean
Cons:
- 700 watts power can mean longer toasting times than stronger toasters
- Only makes two slices at once, which might be slow for big families
- No fancy digital buttons or special features, just simple and easy to use
Amazon Basics 2-Slice Toaster with Wide Slots
The Amazon Basics 2-Slice Toaster is a good choice if you want an easy-to-use toaster that can handle all kinds of bread. It has wide slots that are 5-1/4 inches long and 1-1/4 inches wide. These slots fit bagels, thick bread, muffins, and other big slices without jamming. The toaster uses 900 watts of power, so it toasts bread quickly and evenly. You can choose how dark you want your toast with six different settings. It also has buttons for defrosting frozen bread, canceling the toasting, and toasting bagels.
The toaster is simple to clean because it has a crumb tray that pulls out easily. Its small size makes it fit nicely on your counter and easy to store. The overall build and performance are reliable, making it a good part of your kitchen.
This toaster is best for people who want a versatile and easy machine that can toast thick bread, bagels, and muffins. You can adjust the browning level to get your toast just right.
Some downsides include that it only heats two slices at a time. This may not be fast enough if you have many people to serve. The 900-watt power may cause uneven toasting with some bread types. Also, some customers say the toaster might not last long or perform perfectly every time, with a rating of 4.2 stars.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Toaster for English Muffins
When choosing a toaster for English muffins, size matters—look for wide slots of at least 1.5 inches to prevent squished muffins and uneven toasting. Adjustable browning controls give you the power to achieve that perfect golden crust, while a high-lift lever guarantees easy retrieval without accidental burns. Don’t overlook even toasting capabilities and easy-clean features, because nothing kills breakfast faster than a toaster that’s more trouble than it’s worth.
Proper Slot Size
Choosing the right size for your toaster slots helps you get perfect toasted English muffins without any hassle. For regular muffins, look for slots that are at least 1.25 inches wide. If you like splitting your muffins or have thicker kinds, go for slots that are at least 1.5 inches wide. Wider slots make it easier to put in and take out muffins. They also stop the bread from being squeezed or crushed. The slot length should be at least 4 inches to hold the whole muffin. This way, the muffin toasts evenly and doesn’t hang out or burn. Some toasters have auto-centering guides. These help keep your muffin lined up straight so it browns evenly. The right slot size makes breakfast easier and helps you get crispy, perfectly toasted muffins every time.
Adjustable Browning Settings
Adjustable browning controls let you set how toasted your bread or muffins get. With different options—from light to dark—you can make each slice just the way you like it. These controls help you get consistent results every time. This is especially helpful for small or delicate items like muffins. Toasters with simple dials or digital buttons make it easy to choose your perfect setting. Some toasters also have guides that help center the muffin so it browns evenly. Do you like a little crisp or a very toasted crust? These settings let you pick exactly what you want. They take the guesswork out of toasting, so your breakfast is just right each time.
High-Lift Lever Access
A high-lift lever is a small but handy feature on some toasters. It helps you lift your English muffin higher than normal. This makes it easier and safer to get it out of the toaster. When a muffin is hot and crumbly, it’s easy to accidentally tear it or burn your fingers. The high-lift lever stops that from happening.
Some toasters even have a special button that makes the lever lift automatically when the toast is done. This means you don’t have to stretch or reach into the hot toaster. It adds safety and makes taking out your muffin simple.
This feature is especially helpful for thick bread or small items. It prevents you from having to yank or squeeze, which can cause tearing or messes.
A high-lift lever is a small upgrade that makes toasting easier and safer. It’s worth considering if you like to enjoy your English muffins without hassle.
Even Toasting Capabilities
Since uneven toasting can make an English muffin look and taste bad, it’s important to pick the right toaster. Look for toasters that have auto-centering guides. These guides help position the muffins in the same spot every time, so both halves brown evenly.
A good toaster should have multiple shade settings. This lets you pick how dark or light you want your toast. It helps you get just the right level every time. Also, choose a toaster with big, wide slots. Smaller slots can make muffins tilt or heat unevenly. Big, tall slots keep the muffin steady and help heat wrap around it evenly.
Good toasters keep a steady heat across all the heating parts. Some models even have special insulation. This feature helps the heat stay even and consistent. When your toaster toasts evenly, your breakfast looks better and tastes better.
Ease of Cleaning
Easy-to-clean toasters can save you time and make mornings less messy. Look for toasters with removable crumb trays. These trays can slide out easily, so you can dump out the crumbs without making a mess. A tray that slides smoothly helps keep crumbs from spilling everywhere. Some toasters have anti-jam features. These stop bread from getting stuck inside, so cleaning is simpler. Pick toasters with cleanable surfaces and fewer tight spots. Narrow gaps can hide crumbs and grease, which makes cleaning more work. Regularly take out the crumb tray and wipe inside. This keeps the toaster working well and stops bad smells or taste. A good, easy-to-clean toaster makes mornings easier and keeps crumbs in check.
Safety Features Included
When choosing a toaster for English muffins, safety features matter a lot. Some toasters have auto shutoff. This stops the toaster if it gets too hot or if your toast gets burnt. It helps prevent fires. High-lift levers are helpful too. They let you pull out small muffins easily without burning your fingers. Cool-touch walls keep the outside of the toaster from getting too hot. That way, you won’t accidentally burn yourself. Anti-jam technology stops bread from getting stuck. This keeps the toaster working well and stops it from breaking. Removable crumb trays catch crumbs and prevent smoke or fires. Cleaning these trays is quick and easy. Overall, these safety features make your toaster safer and your mornings less stressful.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Toasters With Removable Crumb Trays Are Easier to Clean?
Yes, toasters with removable crumb trays are easier to clean because you can quickly slide out the tray, dispose of crumbs, and wipe it down. This prevents buildup and keeps your toaster tidy with less effort.
Can a Toaster With Extra-Wide Slots Toast Bagels Effectively?
Yes, a toaster with extra-wide slots can effectively toast bagels. It accommodates thicker items comfortably, ensuring even toasting. Just adjust the browning control for perfect results, making it a versatile choice for bagels and other bulky bread.
How Energy-Efficient Are Modern Toasters for Daily Use?
Modern toasters are quite energy-efficient, consuming minimal electricity while providing quick, consistent toasting. You can save energy daily by choosing models with energy-saving features and using the toaster’s defrost and reheat functions appropriately.
Are There Any Safety Features to Look for in Toasters for English Muffins?
You should look for toasters with auto shut-off, cool-touch exteriors, and crumb trays to prevent fires and messes. These safety features protect you, make cleaning easier, and keep your kitchen environment safe during daily toasting.
Do Smart Toasters Offer Better Control Over Toasting Levels?
Yes, smart toasters offer better control over toasting levels because they allow you to customize settings via apps or digital interfaces. You can precisely set browning levels, monitor toast progress, and save preferences for perfect results every time.
Hello! I’m Eloise Wilson, the culinary enthusiast behind SimplyCookings. Cooking is my canvas and flavors are my palette. I’m here to share easy-to-follow recipes and kitchen wisdom that will make your cooking journey joyful and delicious. Join me and let’s turn everyday meals into extraordinary experiences!
